Andrea Yates and Post Partum Melancholy

Can postpartum depression develop into so invasive as to cause a mom to destroy her children? Since this incredibly almost never takes place, numerous scoff at the prospect. Interestingly enough, postpartum psychosis was to start with recognized as a ailment as far back as 1850. According to Being pregnant Infonet, (2007), scientific studies on the charges of the problem have demonstrated that the number of females enduring postpartum psychosis hasn’t altered considering the fact that the mid 1800s. Pro psychologists, psychiatrists, and behavioral researchers are identifying that postpartum melancholy can, if not dealt with promptly and adequately around an prolonged interval of time most absolutely can escalate to psychosis. Medical professional statements and evaluations, insufficient remedy, and failed suicides are matters that should be thought of in determining Andrea Yates psychological defect at the time of her criminal offense.

It has been argued that owing to some of Yates’ rational and considered out actions that these confirm she was sane at the time of the incident. The fact that, on two occasions she refused medicine and on an additional occasion she stopped having her medication. The truth that she experienced performed a “observe run” of filling up the bathtub and, independently tracked her kids down and drug them to their demise are all arguments that are getting touted as evidence that she experienced whole knowledge of what she was performing.

To recognize the idea of Postpartum despair and Postpartum psychosis, one must initial understand that the two diseases are not synonymous. Postpartum depression is described as a thing that can start at whenever inside just one calendar year of beginning. There is typically disappointment, typical immediately after these types of an ordeal as beginning, and of class a decline of strength, also a popular thing following supplying birth. From time to time there will be a bout with the inability to concentrate, primarily for initially time mothers and along with that, anxiety about motherhood. All these are signs of postpartum melancholy. Not every girl ordeals these and some may perhaps practical experience only a handful of of them. Nonetheless, these signs or symptoms are quite unique than those people of postpartum psychosis. Catherine Roca, (April, 2005)

Dr. Dan Williams, Psy.D., PA-C, “Peace and Healing”, (2006), describes post partum psychosis as “really exceptional”. He goes on to say that “It is characterized by homicidal and suicidal impulses, hallucinations, delusions, disorganized and strange wondering.” Dr. Williams goes on to additional explain some of the constant traits of just one who suffers postpartum psychosis.

“The problem is that these people commonly refuse therapy. This is a health-related crisis condition. If publish-partum psychosis is suspected, households have to have to phone 911 as emergency intervention is necessary. Medication most likely will be prescribed. The supreme intention is to preserve the baby and mom protected.” “Peace and Therapeutic”, (2006)

Yates was initially identified July 21, 1999 as obtaining intense major melancholy by Eileen Starbranch, MD. This diagnoses, came following her attempted suicides. All through her week continue to be at Methodist Clinic Psychiatric Unit, she was diagnosed as having critical major depressive dysfunction, recurrent with psychotic options. More troubles identified were social withdrawal and nominal verbal communications. It was during this psychological analysis that Andrea Yates admitted to having views of hurting herself or somebody else.

Eileen Starbranch, MD, Courtroom Tv, Psychiatric Analysis July (1999) On August 5, 1999, Dr. Starbranch alongside with Dr. Arturo Rics, M.D., experienced a session relating to ongoing care of Andrea. The results of this consultation unveiled that the onset of her despair started about 6 7 days prior alongside with signs and symptoms of psychosis. A lot of the documentation that was reviewed by both doctors indicated that Andrea remained reclusive, guarded and even now had a persistent, depressed mood. Sooner or later Andrea did answer to some diploma to her medication but was warned by Dr. Starbranch not to have an additional boy or girl as this could carry on yet another psychotic episode.

Dr. Arturo Rics, M.D., Dr. Starbranch, MD, Methodist Hospital Psychiatric Heart July (1999) A further psychiatrist, Dr. Melissa R. Ferguson, former clinical director of psychiatric providers at the Harris County Jail, gave testimony that in her impression, Yates was struggling from psychosis. According to Dr. Ferguson, Yates instructed her she thought that the cartoon figures on television ended up telling her how lousy she was for offering her kids “far too substantially candy and cereal”. Ferguson also testified that she thought that Andrea was incapable of knowledge the repercussions of what she did. Dr. Milissa, Former Director, Harris County Jail.

Andrea Yates had all the basic signs or symptoms of article partum psychosis. Even however medication was administered, there was small supervision to ensure that she followed doctor’s orders. Her hospital stays were short and consequently not efficient in a medically supervised natural environment assuring that at ideal the chance of her harming herself or other individuals was sufficiently minimized.

There is absolutely do question in anyone’s intellect that Andrea Yates did in fact drown her little ones in a bathtub. There is no question that the “how” was too horrible to fathom. Due to the fact of the rarity of this issue and its horrendous effects if not taken care of, several People, distinct women, will judge women of all ages like Andrea Yates without compassion for the undergo or the energy to discover and have an understanding of the health issues. What all those folks really should realize is that by comprehension this catastrophic ailment, it in no way condones the steps done as a consequence of that ailment.

In summary, the point out of Texas is to be applauded in its endeavours to recognize this uncommon, nonetheless debilitating and particularly perilous disease. The Andrea Yates bill became affective September 3, 2003 and it states the next:

“Postpartum melancholy (PPD) is a serious ailment, just about every calendar year influencing 10% to 15% of women who have sent young children. This ailment, despite its superior prevalence, typically goes undetected and untreated. In an try to handle this community overall health problem, the State of Texas has enacted legislation, Household Invoice 341 (also acknowledged as the “Andrea Yates Bill”), which went into outcome on September 1, 2003. This regulation needs health care vendors who take care of expecting girls to supply them with source details concerning counseling for postpartum despair and other psychological traumas related with being pregnant and parenting.”
Blue Corss/Blue Protect of TexasPostpartum Despair and Home Monthly bill 341


BlueCross BlueShield of Texas Postpartum Melancholy and Property Bill 341

(2007) Retrieved on September 9, 2007 from the World Broad Website: provider/postpartum.htm

Ferguson, Dr. Melissa R. Former

Healthcare Director of Psychiatric Providers at the Harris County Jail. Retrieved on September 8, 2007
from the Globe Huge Web:

Roca, Catherine , Chief, Women’s Courses, (2005) Despair All through and Immediately after Being pregnant

Countrywide Institute of Mental Wellbeing, (April 2005). Retrieved on September 7, 2007 from the Earth
Broad Net: []

The Being pregnant-Data Workforce, Postpartum Psychosis (2007) Retrieved on September 7, 2007 from the Environment Broad Net:

Starbranch, Eileen, M.D. Court Television

Retrieved on September 9, 2007 from the Globe Vast Internet:

Williams, Dan Psy.D., PA-C, (2006) Peace and Therapeutic.

Retrieved on September 7, 2007 from the World Huge Net:

Share the Post:

Related Posts